Winning the Hardware Software Game Winning the Hardware-Software Game - 2nd Edition

Using Game Theory to Optimize the Pace of New Technology Adoption
  • How do you encourage speedier adoption of your product or service?
  • How do you increase the value your product or service creates for your customers?
  • How do you extract more of the value created by your product or service for yourself?

Read more...

Latest Comments

  • Ron Giuntini said More
    As always a good read.
    I have always... Thursday, 25 January 2018
  • Anonymous said More
    Clearly, phones, and subsequently mobile... Friday, 15 September 2017

Facebook and Google have recently being getting flack from users for hosting fake news stories. As Jack Nicas and Deepa Seethataman report, “Google and Facebook Take Aim at Fake-News Sites”

Facebook Inc. and Alphabet Inc.’s Google announced steps to prevent fake-news websites from generating revenue through their ad-selling services, signs that technology companies are moving to address a growing controversy about misinformation on the internet.

The Fake News Game is illustrated in Figure 1, and players’ objectives, actions, and tensions are described briefly below.

Figure 1

fake news game2

Advertisers

Objective: Maximize User ad clicks

Action: Choose sites, including News Sites and Platforms, to host ads

Given: Existence of both real and fake news and information

 

News Sites

Objectives:

• Generate news stories to attract Users

Maximize revenues from User clicks on hosted ads.

Actions: Generate news stories from available information to attract both Users and Platforms to both read and repost stories

Given:

• Existence of both real and fake news and information

• Costs (e.g., time) of verifying news and information for legitimacy

Tensions:

Real News SitesWant news to be

• Interesting so as to attract Users

• Real so as to maintain reputation for reporting real news

Fake News Sites: Want news to be

• Interesting so as to attract Users

• Similar to Real News so as to avoid being filtered out

 

Platforms

Objectives:

• Host news stories and information to attract Users

• Maximize revenues from User clicks on hosted ads.

Actions:

• Host news stories to attract both Users and Platforms to read and repost stories

• Design algorithms to filter out fake news and information

Given:

• Existence of both real and fake news and information

• Costs (e.g., time) of verifying news and information for legitimacy

Tensions:  Design algorithms, given

• If weed out too much news (i.e., falsely exclude real news), then lose ad revenues

• If weed out too little news (i.e., falsely include fake news), then lose/anger Users

 

Users

Objectives:

• Visit websites that provide interesting news and information

• Generate reputation for passing along (reposting) real and interesting news and information

Actions:

• Choose websites to visit

• Repost interesting news and information

Given:  

• Existence of both real and fake news and information

• Costs (e.g., time) of verifying news and information for legitimacy

Tensions: Choose news and information to repost, given

• If repost too little news and information, then lose reputation

• If repost too much fake news and information, then lose reputation

 

Observations

  • The more difficult it is to verify (and weed out) news and information for accuracy and legitimacy, the more fake news and information will appear.
  • The more fake news there is that is reported or posted, the more difficult (more costly) it is to verify the accuracy of any given piece of news and information. That is, there is a feedback loop here.
  • The lower is the penetration of fake news and information, the greater is the tendency for Users to assume news and information is generally true.
  • However, once a minimum threshold of misinformation has been achieved, Users can no longer assume that news and information is generally true. I think we’ve almost achieved this tipping point.

More Blogs

What Makes the Most Popular TED Talks So Popular?

19-03-2018 - Hits:371 - Ruth Fisher - avatar Ruth Fisher

Suppose a friend told you that he was planning on doing a TED Talk, and he asked your advice on how to make his talk one of the most popular TED Talks out there. What would you tell him? This is exactly the type of question Data Scientists seek to answer...

Read more

Playing the Used Technology Game

09-03-2018 - Hits:887 - Ruth Fisher - avatar Ruth Fisher

Smartphone manufacturers, such as Apple and Samsung, have thrived for the past fifteen years using a specific business model that involves (i) Swiftly releasing next generation products that contain significant advancements over previous generations of products, and (ii) Selling next generation technologies at a premium. However, more recently, sales of used and refurbished...

Read more

Why Is So Difficult to Extract Value from Data?

16-02-2018 - Hits:707 - Ruth Fisher - avatar Ruth Fisher

This is a new idea I'm working on. I'd love to hear any feedback you might have.   We Collect and Analyze Data Why do we collect and analyze data? It informs us about (i) what happened in a given time and place and (ii) why (see Figure 1).  

Read more

The Future of Money

24-01-2018 - Hits:1065 - Ruth Fisher - avatar Ruth Fisher

Traditional currency systems are being assailed from several directions. Some propose digitizing national currencies as a means to decrease transaction costs, facilitate tracking, and discourage illicit uses of currency. Some suggest a single, global currency system is inevitable. Others propose creating non-government-backed forms of currency to eliminate the ability of...

Read more

Switching Costs: The Overlooked Obstacle to Change

18-01-2018 - Hits:541 - Ruth Fisher - avatar Ruth Fisher

Why do we adopt new technologies? Many people will be quick to respond, “Because they help us do things faster, easier, or better.” Pretty obvious. Well, then, why don’t people adopt new technology? Most people would probably say that people don’t adopt new technology either because the technology is too expensive or because people...

Read more

An Example of Game Theory in Risk Management

12-01-2018 - Hits:469 - Ruth Fisher - avatar Ruth Fisher

This analysis was co-authored with Norman Marks, CPA, CRMA and originally posted on his blog.   Many liked the post on Risk and Game Theory with Ruth Fisher (my co-author on the piece). We were asked for more, especially an example or two. As with the last post, I will set the stage and...

Read more

Playing the Sexual Harassment & Misbehavior Game

08-12-2017 - Hits:1064 - Ruth Fisher - avatar Ruth Fisher

Definition of Sexual Harassment Scenarios in the Sexual Harassment & Misbehavior Game Cost to Firms of Sexual Harassment & Misbehavior The Sexual Harassment & Misbehavior Game Musings about the Game Outcomes of the Model   The scourge of the day is sexual harassment. There’s nothing new about sexual harassment. It has always existed. What has changed is the...

Read more

Playing the Restaurant Delivery Game

07-11-2017 - Hits:886 - Ruth Fisher - avatar Ruth Fisher

Remember when restaurant delivery options included Domino’s, Pizza Hut, or Papa John’s? No longer! These pizza restaurants still have a majority share of the restaurant delivery market. However, GrubHub, Eat24, DoorDash, UberEats, and other restaurant delivery platforms are expanding users’ choices beyond just pizza. This analysis examines the Restaurant Delivery Game:...

Read more